Jerusalem, Jerusalem
No words ....
.jpg)
Unasked and Unanswered Question?
May God receive these three children into His loving arms while their parents are left asking how the evil He permits fits with His Divine Providence. Bebe King, aged six, Elsie Dot Stancombe, aged seven, and Alice da Silva Aguiar, aged nine. Perhaps not the right time for these questions. There will be blame aplenty apportioned to the various agencies who failed to identify and prevent this horrific murderous attack. Not to blame them, but any inquiry needs to focus not just on the agencies who failed to pick up on the developing madness of this child. It also needs to look at the mother and father of Axel Rudakubana. Where are parents amidst all these agencies? Is the State responsible? Given all their previous contact with numerous agencies over years, one is forced to ask what the parents needed to help them contend with and help this young, autistic teenager; an isolated child with evident growing mental health problems. What support were they offered?...
I personally am not afraid of nuclear war. I'm only afraid of surviving it. If we wish to avoid it, we need to step back and look at what is happening here from a theological point of view. The problem we have is that -- at least since the Second World War -- we've lost sight of what Christianity, and especially Catholicism, is all about. Let's start from a single question -- is the Mosaic Covenant still in force, or did it end at the moment of Christ's death on the cross? If you hold that it IS still in force, you are a dual covenanter, and there's simply no way around this. Bishop Barron's interview with Ben Shapiro WAS a true reflection of Catholic doctrine in that the Church is merely "the privileged way", but there are others. If that IS your position, then the unqualified, unconditional support of the state of Israel, no matter what it does, is justified.
ReplyDeleteHowever, if you believe the Mosaic Covenant DID end with the crucifixion, then Jews are no more special than any other group of people. They're not cursed, or damned or held in especially odium by God, but they require baptism just the same as everyone else and they have no particular status beyond that of anyone else, including the Palestinians. There's a new covenant in force.
If this is the case, then we need to step back and say, "wait, why are we giving blind, unconditional support to Israel? Is it not time we started looking at this from the same point of view as we did with, say Rhodesia, when another group of white settlers took over a country they didn't own?" We did not accept the racist underpinnings of Ian Smith's Rhodesia; why are we supporting the Israeli equivalent? In a nutshell, what makes Israel so special?
From HJ's point of view, this isn't primarily a theological question. Israel is a State and, as such, has a right to defend herself. Hamas and Iran are terrorists intent on her destruction.
DeleteOne can argue 'til the cows come home about the Balfour Document and the duplicity of Britain towards the Arabs during WW1 and WW2. One can lament the position of the Palestinians and the injustices they face; lament the terrorism behind the early Zionist movement; and the role of America and Russia for geopolitical reasons. All that said, Israel today - 2023 - is a nation State with all the rights and responsibilities that entails.
Facts on the ground?
DeleteSince the entire Israeli claim on Palestine is completely based on a religion, I don't see how the question is not theological. No Christian can accept the Jewish claim unless they are also dual covenanters. If, like me, they are supersessionists, then there is nothing special about Israel. It's a thug state founded and run by racial supremacists. They don't get respectability.
DeleteThe history of secular, cultural, and religious Zionism and the eventual establishment of an Israeli State, is far more complex than your simplistic assertion: "Since the entire Israeli claim on Palestine is completely based on a religion ... "
DeleteYou should do some research.
If I forget thee, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget her cunning.
ReplyDeleteIf I do not remember thee, let my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth; if I prefer not Jerusalem above my chief joy.
The Psalms were written 3000 years ago, Hobb. You're aware there's been a development since then?
Delete