Up to now we've had the competing Julian, Gregorian and Pirelli calendars, but now maybe it's time for one global calendar so all the peoples of the world can live in peace.
When is chair a chair? You'll have to ask Joseph Kosuth.
My birthday at least marks a full revolution around the sun from a fixed (and most auspicious) date, and I accept cake and chocolate so as not to cause my weaker, temporally-blinkered brethren to stumble.
Lunar new year is at least tied to natural cycles. It would make more sense for the new year to mark, say, the start of the seasons and begin in spring. Or, in a Christian country, to begin at the nativity. Or the annunciation, as it did in England from 1155 until 1752 (Gadjo, you omitted the Lady Day calendar!).
Kosuth asks: when is a chair a chair? Metaphysics answers: before the gallery opens.
Fair points. Still, even Aquinas allowed for convenient signs, and January 1st seems a perfectly serviceable one, if only to keep cake consumption synchronised.
Happy New Year Jack ! Great pic of the bridge. Didn't venture out watched it on tv. Still a sombre mood about after the Bondi massacre especially for those of us who live in the area. Hope all is well with you and yours. The Caracas moment has put a cloud over things. ...Prayers and more prayers . All we can do is just keep praying for some sanity to re enter the world....Cressie
Happy Jack, you'll have noticed that tomorrow (Saturday) it's United v. City at Old Trafford. The bookies are offering shorter odds on City. What are your expectations?
Pull up a chair and say hello Happy Jack has discovered how to allow anonymous comments! This is available to those without Google accounts. Just click on the 'Comment' button and select 'Anonymous'. You can give yourself a name too by clicking the 'Name/URL button. There is now a 'Contact' button - on the right of the page - for anyone with any ideas or suggestions about this blog. However, Jack believes one has to have a Google account to use this. If someone has an article they'd like published do send Jack your email address and he'll contact you and let you know his. You'll see from the 'Visits' counter that we've had 2000+ views since week this blog has been running. So please make a comment and keep things going - or not!
"May the LORD rejoice in his works." (Psalm 104:31) The God Who Needs Nothing Genesis does not open by explaining God. It opens with Him speaking, and the first thing said of what He makes is that it is good. Again and again the verdict comes: God saw that it was good. And at the end, complete: "God saw everything that he had made, and indeed, it was very good." Before there is a doctrine of God, there is a Maker Who looks at what He has made and delights in it. The doctrine came later, worked out carefully because so much depended on getting it right. God is one, eternal, uncreated, all-powerful, all-knowing, all-loving, good beyond any goodness we can imagine. He is, in the old phrase, actus purus : no potential left unrealised, nothing in Him still waiting to become something else. Aquinas gave the classical formulation: in God, essence and existence are not two things. God is ipsum esse subsistens , subsistent Being itself. Everything else receives its being. Go...
Yes indeed. Happy new year to one and all. Sing with me:
ReplyDeleteShould auld Aquinas be forgot and never brought to mind...
Only if we also forget the Trinity, metaphysics, and why chairs are still chairs!
DeleteAh, but we'll take a cup of Aquinas yet,
Deletefor auld lang syne... go on go on go on!
Aren't chairs chairs because they conform to the eternal Form of a chair?
DeleteHappy new year to you too (although I don't really understand why we celebrate starting a new calendar, bah humbug),
Well, according to nominalism, it’s only a chair until we stop believing in it—then it’s just a rebellious pile of wood.
DeleteHmmm .... arbitrary units of time, but do you still accept cake and chocolate on your birthday?
Up to now we've had the competing Julian, Gregorian and Pirelli calendars, but now maybe it's time for one global calendar so all the peoples of the world can live in peace.
DeleteWhen is chair a chair? You'll have to ask Joseph Kosuth.
DeleteMy birthday at least marks a full revolution around the sun from a fixed (and most auspicious) date, and I accept cake and chocolate so as not to cause my weaker, temporally-blinkered brethren to stumble.
Lunar new year is at least tied to natural cycles. It would make more sense for the new year to mark, say, the start of the seasons and begin in spring. Or, in a Christian country, to begin at the nativity. Or the annunciation, as it did in England from 1155 until 1752 (Gadjo, you omitted the Lady Day calendar!).
Kosuth asks: when is a chair a chair? Metaphysics answers: before the gallery opens.
DeleteFair points. Still, even Aquinas allowed for convenient signs, and January 1st seems a perfectly serviceable one, if only to keep cake consumption synchronised.
I imagine that the Angelic Doctor would not have been averse to synchronised cake consumption!
DeleteIndeed. Ubi communis mensa, ibi pax. One might argue that cake is a natural law; written on the heart, frosted on the top.
DeleteHello again, Chef, and a happy New Year to you too!
ReplyDeleteWe need the holy water!
DeleteHappy new year to Jack and all here.
ReplyDeleteGood to hear from you, Joe. You've been in my prayers. Have a blessed New Year.
DeleteGreat to see you back here, Mr Bell, if only to post a brief salutation. Here's to a blessed 2026, somehow or other.
DeleteThank you, Jack, and everyone else here. Your prayers are appreciated and I hope to be back more regularly in the future.
DeleteHappy New Year Jack ! Great pic of the bridge. Didn't venture out watched it on tv. Still a sombre mood about after the Bondi massacre especially for those of us who live in the area. Hope all is well with you and yours. The Caracas moment has put a cloud over things. ...Prayers and more prayers . All we can do is just keep praying for some sanity to re enter the world....Cressie
ReplyDeleteAll the best, Cressie, wishing you a happy new year.
DeleteHappy New Year to you and yours, Cressie.
DeleteHappy New Year, Jack and friends!
ReplyDeleteAthbhliain faoi mhaise daoibh, Mr Neanderthal!
Delete.... and Chef of Sinners!
ReplyDeleteHappy New Year Irish Neanderthal.
Happy Jack, you'll have noticed that tomorrow (Saturday) it's United v. City at Old Trafford. The bookies are offering shorter odds on City. What are your expectations?
ReplyDeleteUnited to win .... 2 - 0
Delete